A series of "Why" questions

Posted by Mikey on December 30th, 2007 filed in Uncategorized

Since this blog is called “My Tangential Mind”, I thought it should start living up to that title.  So I have decided to start posting a series of “Why” questions.  These are questions that come into my mind in my everyday life.  No, this is not a rip-off of Seinfeld’s stand-up routine where he asks things like “Why is the place we drive called a parkway and the place we park called a driveway?”  These are just questions that pop into my head as I walk around and see things.

So, without further ado, here is the first question, and a little background:

Why are pirates billed so much as heroes today?  I have been asking myself this for a while, but it recently popped back in my head this morning because I saw Pirate Pig on Dora the Explorer, which happens to be a favorite of my three year old daughter.  Pirate Pig is a good guy, and so is all his crew of pirate pigs. 

I also ask this because I was recently watching Pirates of the Caribbean 3.  I have noticed that while the pirates are shown as dastardly characters in the movie, they are also romanticized and revered.  I realize that they are fighting against some corrupt officials in the British government, but it is still pretty blatant celebration of the pirates despite their evil nature.

I can understand their appeal.  I was fascinated with pirates for a time as a child.  I loved Treasure Island, and I read a lot about them in a book I had when I was a kid.  I was particularly drawn to Blackbeard when I read that he used to weave hemp into his beard and set it on fire.  They had adventures and misadventures, and they thumbed their noses at the authorities.  But all-in-all, I still knew they were murderers and thieves.  So why are they portrayed as good in so many kids shows?  How did that happen?

Mikey


2 Responses to “A series of "Why" questions”

  1. Sam Says:

    Same with outlaws. All these criminals who robbed banks, stages, trains and worse, killed and raped people - they all went down in history with a legacy that depicts them as romanticized characters. Jesse James, Dalton Brothers, Billy the Kid, Sam Bass - all lowly criminals with no character.

  2. Mikey Says:

    Great point Sam.

    My wife and I had a talk with my two sons today about bad guys in movies and books. We don’t restrict them from reading and watching movies that have bad guys in them (except for the obvious stuff that is too much for them at 6 and 5 years old). They have Star Wars characters, Spiderman villians, etc. And my oldest is into this game called Heroscape that has a lot of pretty scary looking characters (some of which he can’t have yet). We talked to them about how it is OK to pretend to be heros and villians, but ultimately they needed to realize that the villians are bad and are not people they need to emulate or revere. I think even at 6 and 5 they understood what we meant, so I feel OK about it. But it just shows how kids can get sucked into the Hollywood version of the bad guy.

Leave a Comment